Hi KC,
My husband and I dove for a week in St. Croix with Cane Bay. The owners Hal and Suzanne are great. If you go, please say hi to them from Michael and Sharyl. St Croix was our very first diving experience outside of our certfication. Cane Bay has a really cool way to enter the water. They are right across from the beach, so you can also do easy-entry shore dives. Hope this was somewhat helpful. Good luck!