Hey Kelly,
Was our last dive at Old Marineland really that cold? ;-)
My wife hates cold water and absolutely LOVES her 7mil Pinnacle Element with merino wool lining. The seals make it practically a semi-dry, and the wool lining probably adds 10% more warmth over standard neoprene. As Zeagle bought Pinnacle recently, Leisure Pro is currently closing them out half price. Sweet deal if they have your size. Check it out.
Rich