Thanks for the report! I dove with Coconut Tree Divers when I was in Roatan. I agree that it is a wonderful location. You have reinforced my determination NOT to dive off a cruise ship excursion. I don’t like to cattle car diving as you describe. Quality is sacrificed when the goal is to get as many divers in the water as possible. Anthony’s Keys normally has a very good reputation. I suspect that they have a hard time refusing what a cruiseline contact can pay. As you mentioned, Roatan is a little and relatively undeveloped spot. A hard place to have a living I am sure!