I stayed at Fantasy Island May 2007. Their pool was a mess, but if you are diving all the time, who cares. Not a luxury resort, but we were well fed and dove as much as we could. Shark dive cost me $75, well worth it. Definitely do the zip line (canopy tour) we liked it so much we went twice. We rented a car one afternoon and took off on our own sightseeing (four SOUTHERN American women who barely spoke spanish)and made it back in one piece, after nightfall.(The road only has ONE stop light on the entire island.)Shower in off times, ie 1hour after everyone comes in off the boats, or there is no water pressure or hot water. Hey, it was an adventure, and yes, I would go back.