MaryW - 6/03/2012 6:41 AM
we rented a condo at Residencias Reef through vrbo that we were so pleased with we’re staying there again in November http://www.vrbo.com/277743, and Blue XT picked us up every day at the dock, plus they take care of all your dive equipment while you’re there. The owner, Christi, baked us something fresh each day plus the fruit! For full disclosure, Christi is a friend of mine, but not a close friend so I don’t think my view is biased.
I would also never miss a massage with Sally at barefootincozumel.com . Last visit I took a very fun cooking class that your non-diver might like http://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g150809-d1441200-Reviews-Josephina_s_Cocina_Con_Alma-Cozumel_Yucatan_Peninsula.html
The "wild" side of the island should also not be missed, imo. The beaches are located there, and some very fun restaurant/bars to hang out and eat good ceviche!!