Meet new scuba divers, maintain a virtual dive log, participate in our forum, share underwater photos, research dive sites and more. Members login here.

Carthaginian - Lahaina, Maui HI

Carthaginian is a boat accessible salt water dive site, located in Lahaina, Maui, HI. This dive site has an average rating of 4.33 out of 5 from 6 scuba divers. The maximum depth is 91-100ft/28-30m. The average visibility is 41-50ft/12-15m.

The Carthaginian is a replica of a double masted brigantine that was sunk off the coast of Lahaina in 2005. For years it was a whaling museum until it just got too costly to maintain. As of last year the mast were still upright which gives it an ominous feeling. However don’t touch it because it may fall at any moment. This is a very nice dive. Saw a very large frog fish hanging on.

Carthaginian II History
  • The original Carthaginian was built in Sweden, as a replica of an 1840s brig, and was used in the 1966 movie "Hawaii" based on James Michener’s novel.

  • The Lahaina Restoration Foundation acquired it and lost it in 1972 when it ran aground leaving for dry-dock on O’ahu.

  • In 1972, the Foundation purchased a German ship christened in 1920 as a two-masted schooner, Carthaginian II. The rigging work was done in Lahaina, using plans researched in England and based on the dimensions of the 1870 brig, Marie Sophie.

  • The Carthaginian II, was a symbol of Lahaina’s days as a 19th century whaling port, made up of 80-foot masts, spars, yards, and iron fittings. She was converted from a commercial bulk carrier used in the Baltic, to a Lahaina landmark.

  • Carthaginian II was a fixture in the Lahaina Harbor since 1973, serving as a museum for visitors and locals alike.

  • She was sold to Atlantis in 2003 at which time they joined in a partnership with Lahaina Divers to begin the procedures for clean-up, permits, and safety protocols for the eventual sinking.

  • It took two years to prepare her for sinking to serve as an artificial reef system. During this time, Lahaina Divers assisted by sinking moorings, pushing through permits, stripping the ship of underwater hindrances, and helping to meet Environments Protection Agency requirements and U.S. Coast Guard requirements.

  • She sank in 27 minutes on Tuesday, 13 December 2005 at 12:13 pm.

  • The dive site where Carthaginian II now rests is approximately 97 feet.

Dive Site Map

Click to Load Map


taylorharris50 - 12/14/2014 8:07 AM
I went scuba diving here on 12/2/2014. Average viz: 71-80ft/22-24m. Water temp: 76-80°F/24-27°C.
The wreck itself isn’t terribly interesting compared to those off of NC but we saw a lot of interesting life down there including eagle rays and large white tip sharks. Great dive.
B4UDive - 8/09/2012 10:48 AM
Rating Added: 4
The Carthaginian has become a great
artificial reef and sits roughly in 90 ft of clear water. Extended
Horizons (dive boat operator) does a great job on getting divers to the site, and their knowledge of the local marine life is unsurpassed. One of the unique aspects of this dive site is that it is routinely visited by Atlantis Submarine.