|
Here’s an image of the device:
|
|
|
Interesting that the promo videos don’t really give me the feeling that I’m hearing what it really sounds like. However, this video does - I guess.
|
|
|
Greg - 8/20/2013 2:38 PM
Seems like an interesting product. I love the innovation but it just doesn’t seem usable. Speech is very hard to understand with a reg in your mouth. I suppose you could develop a cave man language with basic sounds. I wonder what the range is?
|
|
|
...after watching the product videos, and not understanding a WORD they were saying to each other, I felt my hopes for this product disappeared faster than their bubbles!!! ...back to hand signals for the time being!!!
|
|
|
...Hey, can they add a sub-title feature like the videos had (...without which I would have had no idea what was being said!) ...that would make it usable! ;^)
|
|
|
How are you going to tell the difference between somebody talking and somebody farting?LOL
|
|
|
...I guess you’ll have to pay attention where the bubbles are coming from?
|
|
|
I haven’t seen the video yet (blocked at work) but I assume since it’s a bone conduction technology it would be only heard properly when "attached" to one’s head and when played in open air would be hard to hear/recognize anything.
|
|
|
On the other hand this whole subject of talking while scuba diving is it really such a good thing? Your air consumption is increased, I personally know few divers that even if they dive with their significant others they really do appreciate inability to communicate verbally, so what is a point???
|
|
|
...it would be a nice safety device to use with new students, they can freak out a bit when they’re experiencing an issue and don’t have the experience or composure to use hand signals effectively.
|
|
|
Sorry, but I disagree. For most of the students dealing with all these new equipment as it is is very often challenging. Adding yet another gadget would in my opinion complicate it.
That’s why I believe we have confined water dives first (often starting in the shallow water where you can simply stand up and explain issue quickly) than repeat same thing in deep water and than in open water.
But hey it might work fore some... I personally enjoy diving "mute" and than share excitement on the boat with my buddy or group I dove with.
|
|
|
Totally agree with zielit, Another level of difficulty not only for new divers but seasoned ones to.
|
|
|
...just curious, progrower and zielit, are you dive instructors?
|
|
|
|
Not being an instructor doesn’t invalidate your opinion, I truly was just curious
|
|
|
I definitely wouldn’t hang one of these on every student, but occasionally it would be nice to put one on a student who just seems a bit too uncomfortable
|
|
|
I helped out on a couple of open water dives a few weeks ago and the visibility was about 3-5 feet. The current configuration of this device in my opinion would make the dive a little more tricky. Hands free and clearer communication would make it great. Hand signals are pretty straight forward and not up for much interpretation. Where do you do your open waters?
|
|
|
I’ve done certain in a local lake, with viz anywhere between 30 feet to 3 feet. Also done fete dives in the sea of Cortez, with viz between 100 feet and a few feet.
|
|
|
Occasionally a yet-to-be-certified diver gets too stressed to convey their issue with hand signals. It’s not a question of interpretation, they just don’t have the composure to communicate that way.
|
|
|
If they don’t have the composure to communicate with the hand signals they were taught in class I wouldn’t think they are going to talk and make sense either. A simple thumbs up to surface is better then trying to talk over a panicky student. I don’t think they are going to take the time I saw in the video to make the tap on the device then wait then wait agian for a response. I think the concept is great but the current configuration isn’t there yet.
|
|
|
No I’m not instructor, just a dive master with some exposure to learning (assistance during and after DM intern-ship). Still based on my observations and similar discussions with instructors from my shop I don’t think it’s a good idea at least for OWD.
Any other course where you deal with more advanced and already certified divers, that don’t struggle with equipment and buoyancy could be interesting. But they’re usually already OK with hand signals and given good pre-dive briefing there should be no need for such device...
|
|
|
"...and given good per-dive briefing there should be no need for such device..."
Well, fortunately for you’ve never been on a training dive where something has horribly gone wrong. ...unfortunately for me I have, and when that happens you see things VERY differently, and I’ve got to tell you the pre-dive briefing will not come in to play at all during those moments of chaos!
|
|